I found a very interesting article from January 2024 in The Free Press that sheds some light on the claims by the secular left that conservatives want to ban books. In the article, the author James Fishback looked a variety of school districts to see which conservative books they stock in their libraries. Then he compared those numbers with the numbers of liberal books.
Here’s the article from The Free Press:
Over the last couple years, the media have peddled a narrative of “book bans” sweeping the nation. Book bans (ostensibly by the right) are “eating away at democracy,” according to The Guardian, and are “taking an emotional toll,” warned CNN.
[…]So I decided to investigate just how one-sided things actually are. I surveyed the library catalogs of 35 of the largest public school districts in eight red states and six blue states, representing over 4,600 individual schools. All of these records are publicly available online. (Here are just three online catalogs I searched: Broward County, FL, Austin, TX, and Oklahoma City, OK.) What I discovered isn’t so much a problem of banned books. It’s that kids are often exposed to only one side of the story.
And here are the leftist books:
I looked up books written by some of the world’s most well-known progressive thinkers. Here is the percentage, out of the 35 school districts, that stock each book:
Title and Percentage of 35 Districts
The Communist Manifesto (Karl Marx) — 75%
Caste: The Origins of Our Discontent (Isabel Wilkerson) — 60%
The 1619 Project (Nikole Hannah-Jones) — 54%
Stamped (Jason Reynolds and Ibram X. Kendi) — 71%
An African American and Latinx History of the U.S. (Paul Ortiz) — 40%
The New Jim Crow (Michelle Alexander) — 60%
Guide to Political Revolution (Bernie Sanders) — 40%
White Fragility (Robin DiAngelo) — 54%
So You Want to Talk About Race (Ijeoma Oluo) — 57%
This Book Is Anti-Racist (Tiffany Jewell) — 45%
White Rage (Carol Anderson) — 17%
And here are the conservative books:
Meanwhile, I looked up books written by some of the world’s most well-known conservative thinkers. Here is the percentage, out of the 35 school districts, that stock each book:
Capitalism and Freedom (Milton Friedman) — 8%
Created Equal (Dr. Ben Carson) — 5%
Woke Racism (John McWhorter) — 3%
Breaking History (Jared Kushner) — 2%
Social Justice Fallacies (Thomas Sowell) — 0%
The War on the West (Douglas Murray) — 0%
The 1619 Project: A Critique (Phillip W. Magness) — 0%
The Case Against Impeaching Trump (Alan Dershowitz) — 0%
Decades of Decadence (Marco Rubio) — 0%
The Diversity Delusion (Heather Mac Donald) — 0%
The Case for Trump (Victor Davis Hanson) — 0%
This is not surprising for anyone who understands the public school and library industries. These places are staffed and run by secular leftists. So of course they are going to cry about book banning, even when they are the ones banning the books.
Look:
It’s no secret that many school libraries have become reflections of politicized librarians. Take Emily Drabinski, president of the American Library Association and a self-proclaimed Marxist, who said during a socialism conference last September in Chicago that public education “needs to be a site of socialist organizing. I think libraries really do, too. We need to be on the agenda of socialist organizing.”
One last thing, I thought this was a very interesting quote from the article, especially since Christian parents and leaders seem to be fond of blaming men for the decline of dating and marriage:
And is it any surprise that 76 percent of Gen Z and millennial women wouldn’t date a Republican, according to a Change Research poll from September? They’ve likely never been exposed to conservative ideas, and thus, entirely dismiss conservatives as people.
Public schools should be a last resort for education the children of Christians and conservatives. They are not fair and balanced. They are biased. And they are dishonest. If I had children, I would never send them to public schools. I would make sure before marrying that we could afford to homeschool or send the kids to private schools. Government schools and libraries are child abuse.