Byron York explains Mitt Romney’s liberal record as governor of Massachusetts.
To win election as a Republican in Massachusetts, and then to govern effectively, Romney had to align himself with the left side of the GOP. And to do that, he adopted positions that haunt him still.
Perhaps the most fateful was on abortion. Romney’s reputation as a “perfectly lubricated weather vane” — to use the memorable phrase of former rival Jon Huntsman — comes from his decision to run for Senate in 1994 and governor in 2002 as a strongly pro-choice candidate, and then to run for president in 2008 as a strongly pro-life candidate.
According to a new book by Boston journalist Ron Scott, when Romney was planning that ’94 Senate run, he commissioned polling that showed a pro-life candidate could not win statewide election in Massachusetts. So Romney, who said he was personally pro-life, became politically pro-choice.
And not just pro-choice, but ardently pro-choice. “I am not going to change our pro-choice laws in Massachusetts in any way,” Romney said in an Oct. 29, 2002, debate. “I will preserve them. I will protect them. I will enforce them. I do not take the position of a pro-life candidate. I am in favor of preserving and protecting a woman’s right to choose.” When The Boston Globe said there was not a “paper’s width” of difference between Romney and his Democratic opponent on abortion, Romney proudly quoted the paper.
If Romney had chosen a less liberal state to live in, he would not have had to do that — and, of course, he would not have had to switch back to a pro-life position in 2004-2005, as he formed a political action committee and began working toward a run for the Republican nomination for president.
As a candidate for office in Massachusetts, Romney also had to take positions on guns, global warming and gay rights that later caused him difficulties in Republican presidential politics. He even had to renounce Ronald Reagan — an extremely unwise thing to do in today’s GOP. “Look, I was an independent during the time of Reagan-Bush,” Romney said in a 1994 debate with Sen. Ted Kennedy. “I’m not trying to return to Reagan-Bush.” Now, of course, Romney sings Reagan’s praises at nearly every campaign stop.
If he hadn’t run in Massachusetts, he wouldn’t have had to bash Reagan in the first place.
But, after abortion, the most devastating consequence of Romney’s choosing Massachusetts has been the issue of universal health care. In extending coverage to everyone in the state, Romney helped fulfill a long-time liberal goal; just look at the love-fest with Kennedy at the bill’s 2006 signing ceremony. But Romney did not effectively control rapidly rising health care costs. And he could not have anticipated how deeply unpopular universal coverage schemes would become with the Republican base after Obamacare.
In the campaign, Romney has blamed the Democratic Massachusetts legislature for Romneycare’s problems and denied vigorously that he believes his bill would be a good model for the nation. It’s a difficult position to take on his signature achievement in office. And it would not have happened had Romney not chosen to run in Massachusetts.
We can’t afford to run a moderate against Barack Obama – Obama is going to win because he will just point out that Romney agreed with him on everything when he was governor of Massachusetts. Republican voters are pro-life and we oppose government-run health care. we need to elect someone who has a Republican record.
- Why Mitt Romney lost in South Carolina
- Does Mitt Romney’s Romneycare health care plan fund abortion with taxpayer dollars?
- John Hawkins writes the most scathing anti-Romney column EVER
- Santorum and Gingrich expose Romney’s liberal record in Sunday’s NBC debate
- Mitt Romney raised taxes by $740 million while he was governor of Massachusetts
- Mitt Romney and Rick Santorum: who has the pro-life record on abortion?
- RINO Mitt Romney now open to European-style VAT tax
- Is Mitt Romney a flip-flopper? What are his flip-flops?
- RINO Mitt Romney deploys another RINO John Sununu to attack Newt Gingrich
- Mitt Romney supports the anti-Christian and anti-business ENDA law
- Mitt Romney gaffe: Romney fails miserably in interview with Bret Baier
- Jon Huntsman’s anti-Romney ads are awesome
- Mitt Romney’s political views on gay marriage, abortion and global warming
- Mitt Romney flip-flop videos: flat tax, abortion, health care, public sector unions, global warming
- Mitt Romney on global warming, climate change, environmental regulations
- Mitt Romney on abortion and stem cell research in his own words
- White House used Mitt Romney’s Romneycare as a blueprint for Obamacare
- Mitt Romney on the issues: Mitt Romney political views and positions in 2012